QGIS » QGIS Application

Giovanni Manghi wrote:

was the qml created in 2.18?

yes
I also noticed that, when I load a qml in 3.4.1 an Master (regardless of whether it was created with 3.4, 3.5 or 2.x) ,
"visualization type" It automatically switch on "palette"
even if the style had been saved in pseudo color mode

I also noticed that, when I load a qml in 3.4.1 an Master (regardless of whether it was created with 3.4, 3.5 or 2.x) ,
"visualization type" It automatically switch on "palette"
even if the style had been saved in pseudo color mode

this is a different issue (I think) please file a different ticket (with sample data and style), thanks.

I also noticed that, when I load a qml in 3.4.1 an Master (regardless of whether it was created with 3.4, 3.5 or 2.x) ,
"visualization type" It automatically switch on "palette"
even if the style had been saved in pseudo color mode

just tried this in qgis master and can't confirm.

I think this a consequence of removal of the "Load" button to load min/max values from raster layer properties in https://github.com/qgis/QGIS/pull/3871 - it was changed to load min/max when Apply is clicked which I think here interferes with the newly loaded style (once the new min/max values are loaded, the classification is auto-updated from the current color ramp). My preference would be to have the "Load" button back so it is not tied to Apply which is somehow unexpected.

side tip: after loading QML style, you do not need to click Apply or OK. Just press Cancel button and the loaded style should stay... hard to say whether that's a bug or a feature :-)

Martin Dobias wrote:

I think this a consequence of removal of the "Load" button to load min/max values from raster layer properties in https://github.com/qgis/QGIS/pull/3871 - it was changed to load min/max when Apply is clicked which I think here interferes with the newly loaded style (once the new min/max values are loaded, the classification is auto-updated from the current color ramp). My preference would be to have the "Load" button back so it is not tied to Apply which is somehow unexpected.

+1

side tip: after loading QML style, you do not need to click Apply or OK. Just press Cancel button and the loaded style should stay... hard to say whether that's a bug or a feature :-)

... is at the very minimum a very bad ux, borderline bug.

Giovanni Manghi wrote:

I also noticed that, when I load a qml in 3.4.1 an Master (regardless of whether it was created with 3.4, 3.5 or 2.x) ,
"visualization type" It automatically switch on "palette"
even if the style had been saved in pseudo color mode

this is a different issue (I think) please file a different ticket (with sample data and style), thanks.

I think is not a issue but the prefixed behavior for new style manager

Giovanni Manghi wrote:

I also noticed that, when I load a qml in 3.4.1 an Master (regardless of whether it was created with 3.4, 3.5 or 2.x) ,
"visualization type" It automatically switch on "palette"
even if the style had been saved in pseudo color mode

just tried this in qgis master and can't confirm.

the screencasts was recorded on Master 8125366d65

the screencasts was recorded on Master 8125366d65

I'm referring to the second issue, the one that is not part of the description of this ticket (you added as a comment).

Giovanni Manghi wrote:

the screencasts was recorded on Master 8125366d65

I'm referring to the second issue, the one that is not part of the description of this ticket (you added as a comment).

ah ok,
then I need to refile the second one as a new Issue?

I attach the qml saved by Master

is not a matter of qml, explanation has been give here in #20409-6

ah ok,
then I need to refile the second one as a new Issue?

you sure about it? I can't confirm here.

Giovanni Manghi wrote:

ah ok,
then I need to refile the second one as a new Issue?

you sure about it? I can't confirm here.

Yes, I do
Because in screencast qml_style2 it appear this... But I'm not sure It is an issue

Yes, I do
Because in screencast qml_style2 it appear this... But I'm not sure It is an issue

the only issue I see (in your cast) is that when loading the style it is applied correclty it does not switch to "palletted". If you close the properties and reopen them it shows correctly "palletted", is it?

Giovanni Manghi wrote:

Yes, I do
Because in screencast qml_style2 it appear this... But I'm not sure It is an issue

the only issue I see (in your cast) is that when loading the style it is applied correclty it does not switch to "palletted". If you close the properties and reopen them it shows correctly "palletted", is it?

Yes, even if the style is saved by 3.5 in pseudocolor mode when you load it or open it again It automatically switches to palette

this issue appears even in the case of a reclassification of a raster making vain the same reclassification